The friends of Jones' paintings: a case of explanation in the Republic of Art


As of July 2018 University of Brighton Repository is no longer updated. Please see our new repository at

McFee, Graham (2008) The friends of Jones' paintings: a case of explanation in the Republic of Art Contemporary Aesthetics, 6. ISSN 1932-8478

Full text not available from this repository.


All too often the agenda for discussion of institutional accounts of art has been set by George Dickie's (putative) institutional definition of art. To offer a new beginning, the paper addresses the question of explanation with an institutional framework modeled as Terry Diffey’s Republic of Art. In exploring the argumentative resources here, it meets the objection that institutionalism cannot explore the case of so-called ‘first art’: objects created before the concept art came into being. In particular, the paper uses an example to consider how disputes within the Republic might be resolved through rational means, while still maintaining the institutional character of such discussions. For we need not assume that institutionalism has no mechanisms for rational self-correction nor that one, timeless resolution is always possible. Instead, we can find rational activity in the disputes among art critics, as well as contrasting their (broadly contemporary) perspective on the case with the detachment of the (philosophical) aesthetician.

Item Type: Journal article
Uncontrolled Keywords: authoritative body; institutional decisions; Institutionalism; institutional reasons; other-acclamation; Republic of Art; self-election; Terry Diffey
Subjects: L000 Social Sciences > L900 Cultural Studies
V000 Historical and Philosophical studies > V500 Philosophy
L000 Social Sciences > L300 Sociology > L311 Sport and Leisure
Faculties: Faculty of Education and Sport > Chelsea School
Depositing User: Converis
Date Deposited: 13 Oct 2011 08:21
Last Modified: 07 Jan 2013 16:34

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item


Downloads per month over past year